Flavor List

Curated for October 2021

Standard Flavors

Sweet Cream Ice Cream
Sweet Cream is the base ice cream for every Amy’s flavor! It consists of cream, sugar, and eggs. That’s it!

Mexican Vanilla
Our world famous, Mexican Vanilla ice cream is our number one seller! Its unique, wedding cake like flavor comes from crossbreeding a traditional Madagascar vanilla bean with a Mexican orchid.

Cold Press Vanilla
Our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream is made with vanilla from Madagascar that has undone a cold extraction process to harvest the beans. This preserves the flavor by protecting it from high heat normally used in vanilla bean extractions!

Belgian Chocolate 
Our signature Belgian Chocolate ice cream is crafted from fine Belgian Callebaut Chocolate and is high in cocoa yet very mild in taste.

Dark Chocolate
Our decadent Dark Chocolate ice cream is crafted from fine Belgian Callebaut Dark Chocolate that is high in cocoa yet mild in taste.

Coffee
Our Coffee ice cream is made with El Marino Espresso so you can really taste the roasted coffee bean flavor!

OREO®
Invented in 1912 by Nabisco, this legendary cookie has withstood the test of time for over 100 years. With such an iconic taste, it was only right to make an ice cream out of it! This ice cream is made from a combination of our Mexican Vanilla ice cream and plenty of OREO® cookies.

Strawberry
A popular among customers, our Strawberry ice cream is made from our base Sweet Cream ice cream and then blended together with fresh roasted strawberries for that classic Strawberry ice cream flavor!

Each store will have a small selection of the flavors listed below. Please call your favorite store to find out what’s in stock. 

Specialty Flavors

Autumn is Coming
Can you feel a chill in the air? Nothing says fall like our seasonal Pumpkin ice cream, swirled with Cajeta, almond brittle pieces, and pumpkin spice

Banana Chocolate Almond
We took our Banana ice cream and upped the game with crunchy almonds and melt-in-your-mouth soft chocolate chips.

Batter Up
We start with our Sweet Cream ice cream and stir in yellow cake mix for that classic cake batter taste!

Bee Cave Crunch
We take our Mexican Vanilla base and fill it with local honey, cinnamon, pecan pieces and candied pecans.

Brittany’s Parade
Jump for joy and cheer for our Sweet Cream ice cream with fun frosted animal crackers mixed in.

Bruleed Sweet Potato
Step aside sweet potato pie, this flavor is your new go-to fall dessert! Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with house bruleed sweet potatoes, marshmallows, and graham cracker crust pieces

Campfire Treat
Based on your favorite childhood treat, s’mores, our Campfire Treat is a marshmallow-based ice cream with Biscoff cookies and soft chocolate chips.

Cappuccino
Our rich Butter ice cream case with Turkish ground coffee mixed in

Cinnamon
So simple, yet so satisfying! Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with ground cinnamon spice

Coffee & Donuts
Our El Marino Espresso Coffee ice cream mixed together with sour cream donuts

Coffee Almond Crunch
A pleasing blend of our Coffee ice cream, crunchy almond pieces, and melt-in-your-mouth soft chocolate chips

Cranberry Breeze
Our Sweet Cream ice creams with roasted cranberries and marshmallows mixed in

Custard Donut
Our classic Custard ice cream with glazed donuts added to the mix.

Dark Bark
Our decadent Dark Chocolate ice cream with pieces of house made peppermint bark stirred in

Dry Eggnog
Get into the holiday spirit with our Custard ice cream combined with a dash of ground cinnamon and nutmeg for that iconic eggnog taste!

Eggnog
*This flavor contains alcohol.* Our Custard ice cream blended with a festive blend of rum, brandy, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

Espresso
Our Coffee ice cream blended with Turkish ground coffee for a double dose of espresso flavor!

Fruit Cake
*This flavor contains alcohol.*Ice Cream Mix, Cold Press Vanilla, Spice Cake, Pecan Pieces, Brandy, Raisins, Dates

Gingerbread Pancake
Our Sweet Cream ice cream is mixed with molasses, gingersnaps, and the always essential maple syrup for a remarkable gingerbread pancake flavor!

Guinness Gingerbread
*This flavor contains alcohol.* Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with Guinness beer and lots of ginger snap cookies.

Honeyed Brandy
*This flavor contains alcohol.* Our Honey ice cream mixed with ground cinnamon and a splash of brandy.

Mango
Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with a pureed mangos

Maple Ginger Pecan
We are bringing fall flavors back to the table with our Maple ice cream blended with ground ginger and pecan pieces!

Marshmallow Peanut Butter Cup
Our Marshmallow ice cream mixed together with crushed peanut butter cups!

Merry Mocha
A blend of our Dark Chocolate and Coffee ice creams with house made Peppermint Bark pieces stirred in

Mint Condition
Our Butter ice cream blended with peppermint oil and house made peppermint bark pieces stirred in

Mint Julep
*This flavor contains alcohol.* Based on the well known Mint Julep cocktail, this flavor is our Sweet Cream ice cream infused with fresh mint and a splash of bourbon!

Mint OREO®
Our Peppermint ice cream mixed together with an abundance of OREO® cookies.

Mississippi Mud Pie
Inspired by the Mississippi Mud Cake/Pie dessert, this flavor contains a combination of our Dark Chocolate and Mexican Vanilla ice creams with pecan pieces, marshmallows, and OREO® cookies!

Mocha Chocolate Cake
A barista approved blend of our Coffee and Belgian Chocolate ice creams with house made chocolate cake pieces

Nutmeg
Our Sweet Cream blended with Nutmeg to create a warm and aromatic flavor reminiscent of the holidays

Peppermint
Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with refreshing peppermint oil

Peppermint Stick
Our Sweet Cream ice cream mixed with peppermint stick crumbles.

Pecan Pie
Known as the official pie of the state of Texas, Pecan Pie is a Texas staple. Our Pecan Pie ice cream consists of our Cold Press ice cream and whole pecan pies!

Pistachio
The best pistachio ice cream you’ll ever try! Our Sweet Cream ice cream is infused with amaretto extract and mixed with lots of pistachios!

Popcorn
Exactly what it sounds like! Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with savory, buttery popcorn!

Pumpkin Latte
Our Coffee ice cream is blended together with pureed pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, ginger for the perfect pumpkin spice latte flavor!

Rusted Shut
*This flavor contains alcohol.* Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with biscotti pieces, crushed up toffee, and a splash of whiskey.

Saturday Morning Cartoons
Remember the days of waking up in the morning with a bowl of cereal and watching your favorite cartoons? Our Sweet Cream ice cream that’s been infused with Fruit Loops will remind you of those glory days!

Shiner
*This flavor contains alcohol.* Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with a local Texas favorite, Shiner Bock beer.

Silk Chocolate
An ultra decadent mixture of both our Dark Chocolate and White Chocolate ice creams.

Snickerdoodle
Our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream combined with Nutella and ground cinnamon.

Spice of Fall
This is the ultimate ice cream to ring in the fall season, with the warm flavors of cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, and ginger, plus toasty Biscoff Sandwich Cookies

Texas Dirt Cake
One of our customers’ all time favorite flavors, try this Dark Chocolate ice cream combined with a sweetened cream cheese, lemon juice, and plenty of OREO® cookies!

Thai Tea
Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with a strong Thai Tea infusion

Tito’s The Dude
*This flavor contains alcohol.* Inspired by The Big Lebowksi, this flavor is our take on the Dude’s favorite beverage. Sweet Cream ice cream blended with Kahlua and Tito’s Vodka. The Dude abides!

Trail Of Mint
Ice Cream Mix, Creme de Menthe, Peppermint Oil, Peppermint Bark

Triple Berry Tres Leches
Inspired by the most popular cupcakes from Baked by Amy’s, this flavor starts with a Tres Leches base with fluffy white cake pieces mixed in and swirled with a three berry jam made of strawberries, blueberries, and blackberries.

Triple Mexxx
How can we make our most famous flavor even more famous? By adding more of the famous, magic ingredient! Our Mexican Vanilla ice cream, but with more of our Mexican Vanilla extract added for even more flavor than ever before!

Whopper
Based on the popular malted milk ball candy, our Whopper ice cream is made from our Belgian Chocolate ice cream, malt powder, and melt-in-your-mouth soft chocolate chips.

Wish it Were Fall
*This flavor contains alcohol.* Ice Cream Mix, Cold Press Vanilla, Spice Cake, Cream Cheese, Dates, Nutmeg, Cinnamon, Rum

Zilker Mint Chip
One of our top selling flavors, Zilker Mint Chip ice cream has become a staple and a must try at Amy’s. Our Zilker Mint Chip is made from our Sweet Cream ice cream that’s been mixed together with creme de menthe, peppermint oil, and of course melt in your mouth soft chocolate chips!

 

Fruit Ices

Apple Cider
A non-dairy, sorbet like dessert made with apple cider

Cran Apple
A non-dairy, sorbet like dessert made with cranberry juice and apple juice

Mango
A non-dairy, sorbet like dessert made with pureed mangos

Mango Ginger Cayenne
A non-dairy, sorbet like dessert made with pureed mangos, fresh ginger, and cayenne pepper

Pineapple Cherry
A non-dairy, sorbet like dessert made with pureed pineapple and cherries

Strawberry Lemonade
A non-dairy, sorbet like dessert made with pureed strawberries and lemon juice

 

Vegan Flavors

Oat Milk Chocolate
Our plant based ice cream made with a sweet oat milk base and blended with rich chocolate.

Oat Milk Mexican Vanilla
Our plant based ice cream made with a sweet oat milk base and our signature Mexican Vanilla extract

Vegan Chocolate
Our plant based ice cream made with a coconut milk base, cocoa, and sweetened with agave!

Vegan Coffee
Our plant based ice cream made with a coconut milk base and El Marino espresso

Vegan Mexican Vanilla
Our plant based ice cream made with a coconut milk base, our signature Mexican Vanilla extract, and sweetened with agave!