Flavor List

Curated for September 2023

Standard Flavors

Sweet Cream Ice Cream
Sweet Cream is the base ice cream for every Amy’s flavor! It consists of cream, sugar, and eggs. That’s it!

Mexican Vanilla
Our world-famous, Mexican Vanilla ice cream is our number one seller! Its unique, wedding cake-like flavor comes from crossbreeding a traditional Madagascar vanilla bean with a Mexican orchid.

Cold Press Vanilla
Our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream is made with vanilla from Madagascar that has undone a cold extraction process to harvest the beans. This preserves the flavor by protecting it from high heat normally used in vanilla bean extractions!

Belgian Chocolate
Our signature Belgian Chocolate ice cream is crafted from fine Belgian Callebaut Chocolate and is high in cocoa yet very mild in taste.

Dark Chocolate
Our decadent Dark Chocolate ice cream is crafted from fine Belgian Callebaut Dark Chocolate that is high in cocoa yet mild in taste.

Coffee
Our Coffee ice cream is made with El Marino Espresso so you can really taste the roasted coffee bean flavor!

OREO®
Invented in 1912 by Nabisco, this legendary cookie has withstood the test of time for over 100 years. With such an iconic taste, it was only right to make an ice cream out of it! This ice cream is made from a combination of our Mexican Vanilla ice cream and plenty of OREO® cookies.

Strawberry
A popular among customers, our Strawberry ice cream is made from our base Sweet Cream ice cream and then blended together with fresh roasted strawberries for that classic Strawberry ice cream flavor!

Each store will have a small selection of the flavors listed below. Please call your favorite store to find out what’s in stock. 

Vegan Flavors

Oatly Belg
Our classic Belgian Chocolate flavor is made with Oatly milk for a rich and creamy, yet dairy-free treat!

Oatly Mex
Our Mexican Vanilla flavor with an Oatly Milk base makes a dairy-free treat so rich and flavorful

Oatly Pumpkin
Our Pumpkin flavor with an Oatly Milk base makes a dairy-free treat so rich and flavorful

Rich’s Belgian Chocolate
Sweet, decadent Belgian chocolate chips melted and mixed with Rich’s oat milk for a delicious, dairy-free treat

Rich’s Mex
Our classic Mexican Vanilla is carefully crafted with Rich’s Oat milk for our dairy-free friends to enjoy this Amy’s staple

Rich’s Pumpkin
Our signature Pumpkin flavor is a delicious, dairy-free treat made with Rich’s oat milk.

Fruit Ices

Apple Cider

Pureed apples, Brown Sugar, and Cinnamon frozen into a dairy-free, sorbet-like dessert.

Blackberry Lime

Indulge in the perfect summer non-dairy treat, blending roasted blackberries’ sweet richness with a zesty burst of lime juice, all harmoniously united. This frozen delight is a symphony of tastes that will cool and delight you on any warm day, creating an unforgettable and refreshing treat.

Coke Frosty

A non-dairy sorbet-like dessert made with Classic Coca-Cola soda.

Mango

Our Mango ice is made from a mixture of water and mangoes!

Orange Kool Aid

OH YEAH! A delightful non-dairy treat that captures the nostalgic essence of Orange Kool-Aid. Each bite will transport you to a world of fun and refreshment. With every bite, you’ll relish the joy of childhood memories and the simple pleasures of this classic flavor.

*Alcohol Flavors*

Anchors Away*
Ahoy Matey! Our delicious Mexican Vanilla ice cream mixed together with Dr. Pepper and Sailor Jerry’s Rum.  *This flavor contains alcohol.*

Bad to the Bone*
A Scotch, a bourbon and a beer walk into an ice cream machine…wait! That’s not how it goes… A special blend of scotch, bourbon and Shiner Bock beer blended with Sweet Cream ice cream. *This flavor contains alcohol.*

Red Rum*
Red Rum… Red Rum… Those words might make you scared, however, this Sweet Cream ice cream blended together with Big Red, a cream soda invented in Waco, Texas, and rum will have you screaming with joy! *This flavor contains alcohol.*

Rusted Shut*
Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with biscotti pieces, crushed up toffee, and a splash of whiskey. *This flavor contains alcohol.*

Waterloo Lavender Gin*
Our Lavender ice cream blended with a splash of local Waterloo Gin *This flavor contains alcohol.*

Witches Brew*
Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with mulled wine. *This flavor contains alcohol.*

Mint Variations

After Dinner Mint
A rich blend of our Butter, Dark Chocolate, and Peppermint ice creams blended with soft chocolate chips

Booger Monster
Our Peppermint ice cream with Creme de Menthe for a pop of green color, mixed with soft chocolate chips and marshmallows

Peppermint
Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with refreshing peppermint oil

Peppermint Patty
Our Peppermint ice cream swirled with our delectable house-made fudge.

ZMC-Zilker Mint Chip
One of our top selling flavors, Zilker Mint Chip ice cream has become a staple and a must try at Amy’s. Our Zilker Mint Chip is made from our Sweet Cream ice cream that’s been mixed together with creme de menthe, peppermint oil, and of course melt in your mouth soft chocolate chips!

Specialty Flavors

Tasting Tuesday- Butterscotch Brownie

Our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream with mouthwatering homemade butterscotch blended in

ice cream mixed with brownie bites from Baked by Amy’s

Autumn Day Crunch

Our Maple ice cream with Pecan Sandies and Candied Pecans will get you in the autumn spirit!

Bee Cave Crunch

Our Mexican Vanilla ice cream is blended with local honey, cinnamon, pecan pieces, and candied pecans to create one of our most beloved flavors.

Butterfinger

Our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream with chunks of Butterfinger candy bars blended in to create crispety, crunchety, peanut-buttery perfection.

Our Maple ice cream with Pecan Sandies and Candied Pecans will get you in the autumn spirit!

Candy Carnival

A tasty fun ride of cotton candy flavored ice creams with cotton candy pieces swirled inside.

Caramel Apple

Sweet cream with pecan praline, delicious apple butter, and whipped cream swirled throughout.

Chocolate Orange Chip

Belgian Chocolate ice cream blended with orange juice and melt-in-your-mouth soft chocolate chips

German Chocolate Cake

Fun fact: German Chocolate Cake was originally invented in 1852 by Samuel German and popularized in Texas. Try our take on it! Dark Chocolate ice cream mixed with shredded coconut, pecan praline, homemade whipped cream, and delicious hunks of chocolate cake

German Rum Ball

Belgian Chocolate ice cream mixed with a white cake that has been soaked with rum.

Gingerbread Pancake

Our Sweet Cream ice cream is mixed with molasses, gingersnaps, and the always essential maple syrup for a remarkable gingerbread pancake flavor!

Pink Ribbon

Cold Press Vanilla ice cream with a  Raspberry Jam Swirl mixed with Biscoff Cookies.

Red Velvet Birthday Cake

An indulgent blend of our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream with red velvet cake pieces mixed in

Rice Krispy Treat

Snap, crackle, pop Rice Krispies! Our Marshmallow ice cream combined with Rice Krispies to satisfy that no!

Trick or treat 

Belgian Chocolate ice cream with Kit Kats, Heath Bar, and Butterfingers mixed in.

Whopper

Based on the popular malted milk ball candy, our Whopper ice cream is made from our Belgian Chocolate ice cream and is mixed together with malt, and melt in-your-mouth soft chocolate chips.

Apple Butter 

Our Sweet Cream ice cream with apple butter pureed into the mix.

Big Red
Developed in 1937 in Waco, TX, Big Red has been a favorite among Texans for decades. Our Big Red flavor is our Sweet Cream ice cream blended together with this iconic soda!

Butter Beer
Get magical with our Butter ice cream mixed together with butterscotch and cream soda!

Lavender
Our Sweet Cream ice cream mixed with dried lavender tea infusion, which adds a welcome floral flavor.

Mangonada
Our take on the popular Mexican dessert! A complex blend of our Mango ice cream with a chamoy swirl

Pumpkin
Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with pumpkin puree, cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, and ginger.

Pumpkin Spiced Latte
Our delightful Coffee ice cream with a splash of pumpkin spice

Strawberry Lavender
Sweet Cream ice cream infused with Lavender and roasted strawberries throughout.  

Tang
Enjoy your ice cream like an astronaut! Our Sweet Cream ice cream with NASA’s favorite drink mix, Tang, creates a nostalgic dreamsicle flavor