Flavor List

Curated for June 2021

Standard Flavors

Sweet Cream Ice Cream
Sweet Cream is the base ice cream for every Amy’s flavor! It consists of cream, sugar, and eggs. That’s it!

Mexican Vanilla
Our world famous, Mexican Vanilla ice cream is our number one seller! Its unique, wedding cake like flavor comes from crossbreeding a traditional Madagascar vanilla bean with a Mexican orchid.

Cold Press Vanilla
Our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream is made with vanilla from Madagascar that has undone a cold extraction process to harvest the beans. This preserves the flavor by protecting it from high heat normally used in vanilla bean extractions!

Belgian Chocolate 
Our signature Belgian Chocolate ice cream is crafted from fine Belgian Callebaut Chocolate and is high in cocoa yet very mild in taste.

Dark Chocolate
Our decadent Dark Chocolate ice cream is crafted from fine Belgian Callebaut Dark Chocolate that is high in cocoa yet mild in taste.

Coffee
Our Coffee ice cream is made with El Marino Espresso so you can really taste the roasted coffee bean flavor!

OREO®
Invented in 1912 by Nabisco, this legendary cookie has withstood the test of time for over 100 years. With such an iconic taste, it was only right to make an ice cream out of it! This ice cream is made from a combination of our Mexican Vanilla ice cream and plenty of OREO® cookies.

Strawberry
A popular among customers, our Strawberry ice cream is made from our base Sweet Cream ice cream and then blended together with fresh roasted strawberries for that classic Strawberry ice cream flavor!

Each store will have a small selection of the flavors listed below. Please call your favorite store to find out what’s in stock. 

Specialty Flavors

After Dinner Mint
A rich blend of our butter ice cream and hints of dark chocolate with Creme de Menthe, peppermint, and soft chocolate chips.

Ancho Chocolate
Ancho chili peppers steamed and pureed into our chocolate ice cream mix

Bad to the Bone
This flavor contains alcohol. A Scotch, a bourbon and a beer walk into an ice cream machine…wait! That’s not how it goes… A special blend of scotch, bourbon and Shiner Bock beer blended with Sweet Cream ice cream.

Becky’s Bear
Our to-die-for Honey Butter ice cream with lots of Teddy Grahams mixed in

Beer & Pretzels
This flavor contains alcohol. Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with a splash of Shiner Bock beer, and pretzels.

Beets, Basil & Battlestar Goatlatica
This is for all The Office fans! Dwight would approve of our Roasted Beet ice cream with hints of savory basil and goat cheese.

Big Boy Breakfast
Our Big Boy Breakfast ice cream starts with our Sweet Cream ice cream and is mixed with maple syrup, ground cinnamon, and waffle cone pieces.

Blueberry Pop Tart
What’s your favorite Pop Tart flavor? Blueberry Pop Tarts were one of the 4 original Pop Tart flavors to come out in 1967. Our Blueberry Pop Tart ice cream is made from our Sweet Cream ice cream that’s been mixed together with blueberry jam, whipped cream, and of course Blueberry Pop Tarts!

Brittany’s Parade
Jump for joy and cheer for our Sweet Cream ice cream with fun frosted animal crackers mixed in.

Cheesecake Brownie
Our Cheesecake Ice Cream with homemade brownie bites from Baked by Amy’s mixed in.

Chewy Butter Crunch
Our rare Browned Butter ice cream is filled to the brim with homemade toffee from Baked by Amy’s, Belgian Callebaut caramel cups, plentiful soft chocolate chips and a hint of sea salt. This is the flavor of the year and you can chew on that!

Chocolate Cake Explosion
Satisfy your taste buds with our chocolate cake batter ice cream, made with pasteurized egg yolks for that delicious custard taste, chocolate cake pieces, and rainbow sprinkles.

Coffee Heath
Our Coffee ice cream is made with roasty El Marino Espresso and blended with crushed, crunchy Heath Bars

Dreamsicle
Our Mexican Vanilla ice cream is blended with orange juice for that nostalgic creamy citrus flavor we all know and love!

French Toast
Do you like French Toast? Yeah we like French Toast! This Custard ice cream combined with maple syrup, vanilla extract, cinnamon, and delectable pieces of pound cake will satisfy any need for French Toast, no matter what time it is!

French Vanilla
Our Custard ice cream mix blended with vanilla extract is frozen French Vanilla perfection!

Fuzzy Navel
This flavor contains alcohol. A fresh blend of Sweet Cream ice cream, orange juice, and peach schnapps.

Ice Cream Sandwich
Yup, you read that right. Ice cream sandwich flavored ice cream. We blend our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream with those iconic chocolate wafers that fans of ice cream sandwiches will instantly recognize!

Jalapeno Popper
Like some kick to your ice cream? Try our Cheesecake ice cream mixed with roasted jalapenos, lime juice, and house candied bacon!

Malted Belgian Chocolate
Our Belgian Chocolate ice cream combined with malt powder for that classic, soda shop taste!

Maple Bacon
Who says bacon and ice cream don’t go together? Our Sweet Cream ice cream mixed with maple syrup and candied bacon is for all the bacon lovers out there!

Maple Ginger Pecan
We are bringing fall flavors back to the table with our Maple ice cream blended with ginger and pecan pieces!

Marshmallow
Our Sweet Cream ice cream mixed together with melted down marshmallows to make a special Marshmallow flavor!

Mint Chip
Our Peppermint ice cream mixed together with melt in your mouth chocolate chips.

Mint Chip Cookie Dough
A mint chocolate lover’s delight! This flavor melds together peppermint, Creme de Menthe and chunks of our house made chocolate chip cookie dough!

Mint Ice Cream Sandwich
Our Peppermint ice cream with those iconic chocolate sandwich wafers stirred in.

Mint OREO®
Our Peppermint ice cream mixed together with an abundance of OREO® cookies.

Nutella S’mores
We wanted to take our Big Kid S’mores up a notch and the most famous chocolate hazelnut spread was the way to go. Nutella ice cream with fluffy marshmallows and crushed Biscoff cookies!

Peach Cobbler
A Southern United States favorite, our Peach Cobbler ice cream is made from Sweet Cream ice cream blended with roasted peaches, a dash of cinnamon, and crushed up Nilla Wafers

Peanut Butter & Honey Sandwich
Our nutty Peanut Butter ice cream combined with honey and graham crackers to make the perfect afternoon (or midnight!) snack.

Peppermint
Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with refreshing peppermint oil.

Popcorn
Exactly what it sounds like! Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with buttery popcorn!

Pralines & Cream
A divine mix of Vanilla ice cream with our famous Pecan Praline, blended with whipped cream and crunchy candied pecans!

Real Good Ice Cream
NEW: Velvety crème pâtissière (the excellent stuff piped into cream puffs) churned into rich frozen custard packed with house-made melt-in-your-mouth chocolate chip cookie dough chunks, crunchy Biscoff cookies, and Buncha Crunch® chocolate candy pieces.

Rice Krispy Treat
Snap, crackle, pop Rice Krispies! Our Marshmallow ice cream combined with Rice Krispies to satisfy that childhood nostalgia sweet tooth!

Rocky Road
A classic ice cream combo, our Rocky Road is made from Dark Chocolate ice cream mixed with almond pieces, walnuts, marshmallows, and melt in your mouth soft chocolate chips!

Salted Caramel
Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with sweet and savory salted caramel!

Shiner
This flavor contains alcohol. Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with a local Texas favorite, Shiner Bock beer.

Strawberry Banana
A beloved flavor pairing, our Strawberry Banana ice cream is made from our Sweet Cream ice cream, blended with roasted strawberries and pureed banana!

Street Corn
Inspired by the Mexican street snack elote, we combine our Sweet Cream ice cream with sweet corn, lime juice, and Tajin seasoning

Tito’s the Dude
Inspired by The Big Lebowksi, this flavor is our take on the Dude’s favorite beverage. Sweet Cream ice cream blended with Kahlua and Tito’s Vodka. The Dude abides!

Triple Mexxx
How can we make our most famous flavor even more famous? By adding more magic to it of course! This ice cream is our Mexican Vanilla, but with more of our Mexican Vanilla extract added to it for even more flavor than ever before!

Whiskey Caramel
This flavor contains alcohol. Our Sweet Cream ice cream combined with caramel and a splash of whiskey.

Zilker Mint Chip
One of our top selling flavors, Zilker Mint Chip ice cream has become a staple and a must try at Amy’s. Our Zilker Mint Chip is made from our Sweet Cream ice cream that’s been mixed together with creme de menthe, peppermint oil, and of course melt in your mouth soft chocolate chips!

Fruit Ices

Aloha
Get in the aloha spirit with our refreshing Aloha ice, made from a mix of water, pureed pineapple, and creme de coconut!

Cantaloupe
Our Cantaloupe ice is made from a mixture of water, pureed cantaloupe, and lemon juice!

Mangonada
Much like the popular frozen dessert, our Mangonada ice is made from mango puree, Chamoy, and Tajin seasoning.

Mint Cucumber
Our Mint Cucumber ice is made from a mixture of water, cucumber puree, lime juice, and pureed fresh mint!

Strawberry Lemonade
Our Stawberry Lemonade ice is made from a mixture of water, pureed strawberries, and lemon juice!

Vegan Flavors

Oat Milk Chocolate
Oat Milk, Chocolate, Cornstarch, Xanthan Gum

Oat Milk Mexican Vanilla
Oat Milk, Mexican Vanilla Extract, Cornstarch, Xanthan Gum

Vegan Chocolate
Coconut Milk, Cocoa powder, Agave, Cornstarch, Xanthan Gum

Vegan Mexican Vanilla
Coconut Milk, Mexican Vanilla Extract, Agave, Cornstarch, Xanthan Gum

Vegan Mango
Coconut Milk, Mango, Agave, Cornstarch, Xanthan Gum