Flavor List

Curated for September 2021

Standard Flavors

Sweet Cream Ice Cream
Sweet Cream is the base ice cream for every Amy’s flavor! It consists of cream, sugar, and eggs. That’s it!

Mexican Vanilla
Our world famous, Mexican Vanilla ice cream is our number one seller! Its unique, wedding cake like flavor comes from crossbreeding a traditional Madagascar vanilla bean with a Mexican orchid.

Cold Press Vanilla
Our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream is made with vanilla from Madagascar that has undone a cold extraction process to harvest the beans. This preserves the flavor by protecting it from high heat normally used in vanilla bean extractions!

Belgian Chocolate 
Our signature Belgian Chocolate ice cream is crafted from fine Belgian Callebaut Chocolate and is high in cocoa yet very mild in taste.

Dark Chocolate
Our decadent Dark Chocolate ice cream is crafted from fine Belgian Callebaut Dark Chocolate that is high in cocoa yet mild in taste.

Coffee
Our Coffee ice cream is made with El Marino Espresso so you can really taste the roasted coffee bean flavor!

OREO®
Invented in 1912 by Nabisco, this legendary cookie has withstood the test of time for over 100 years. With such an iconic taste, it was only right to make an ice cream out of it! This ice cream is made from a combination of our Mexican Vanilla ice cream and plenty of OREO® cookies.

Strawberry
A popular among customers, our Strawberry ice cream is made from our base Sweet Cream ice cream and then blended together with fresh roasted strawberries for that classic Strawberry ice cream flavor!

Each store will have a small selection of the flavors listed below. Please call your favorite store to find out what’s in stock. 

Specialty Flavors

Alexander’s Sister
*This flavor contains alcohol* Based on the classic cocktail, this flavor is our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with Gin, Creme de Menthe, and nutmeg!

Ancho Chile Pepper
Looking for something spicy? Our Ancho ice cream flavor hits the spot with a Sweet Cream base with an ancho chile pepper infusion.

Apple Bourbon Butterscotch
*This flavor contains alcohol* Our Sweet Cream ice cream with apple flavored bourbon and house made butterscotch

B-52
*This flavor contains alcohol* A Sweet Cream ice cream base with Kahlua Coffee Liqueur, Irish Cream, and Grand Marnier.

Bourbon Pecan
*This flavor contains alcohol* Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with bourbon and pecan candy

Brown Sugar Poptart
Long debated as the best Pop Tart flavor, Brown Sugar Pop Tarts were one of the 4 original Pop Tart flavors to come out in 1967. Our Brown Sugar Pop Tart ice cream is made from our Sweet Cream ice cream that’s been mixed together with brown sugar, and of course Brown Sugar Pop Tarts!

Chocolate Cake Explosion
Satisfy your taste buds with our chocolate cake batter ice cream, chocolate cake pieces, and rainbow sprinkles.

Chocolate Coconut Rum
*This flavor contains alcohol* Dark Chocolate ice cream blended together with coconut flakes and coconut liqueur.

Coconut Almond Crunch
Our Sweet Cream ice creams blended with melt-in-your-mouth soft chocolate chips, almond pieces, and shredded coconut

Cookie Butter Crunch
Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with decadent Biscoff Cookie Butter and house made waffle cone pieces

Dreamsicle
Our Mexican Vanilla ice cream is blended with orange juice for that nostalgic creamy citrus flavor we all know and love!

French Vanilla
Our Custard ice cream mix blended with cold pressed vanilla extract is frozen French Vanilla perfection!

Grasshopper
*This flavor contains alcohol* Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with Creme de Menthe and Creme de Cacao.

Ice Cream Sandwich
Yup, you read that right. Ice cream sandwich flavored ice cream. We blend our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream with those iconic chocolate wafers that fans of ice cream sandwiches will instantly recognize!

Lit Mint
This minty flavor takes it up a notch. Our Peppermint ice cream blended Andes Mints and Mint OREO® Cookies.

Malted Mint
Our Peppermint ice cream blended with toasty malt powder.

Marshmallow
Our Sweet Cream ice cream mixed together with melted down marshmallows to make a special Marshmallow flavor!

Matcha Snap
Matcha Green Tea ice with bright and crunchy Lemon Cookies

Mexican Candy
Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with Molasses, Butter, Brown Sugar, Candied Pecans, and Pecan Pieces

Midnight Snack
Ever get the munchies in the middle of the night? Our Dark Chocolate ice cream mixed together with peanut butter, crushed Ritz Crackers, and crushed pretzels will crush those midnight cravings!

Mint OREO®
Our Peppermint ice cream mixed together with an abundance of OREO® cookies.

The MK Special
Amy’s has created the MK Special in honor of customer Mary Katherine who, at the
age of 4, passed away from an aggressive and incurable brain cancer called
DIPG. Near the end of her life when she wasn’t able to eat much else, Mary Katherine could still eat ice cream. Her parents took her to Amy’s every day for Belgian Chocolate ice cream with crushed M&Ms, what they lovingly referred to as the MK Special.

Mocha
A blend of our Belgian Chocolate and Coffee ice creams

Mocha Heath
A blend of our Coffee and Belgian Chocolate ice creams with crushed Heath Bar

Nutella
Our Dark Chocolate ice cream blended with the famous chocolate hazelnut spread, Nutella!

Peanut Butter & Jelly
The granddaddy of all flavor combinations! Enjoy a timeless flavor combo with our Peanut Butter ice cream that’s swirled with strawberry jam!

Peanut Butter OREO®
Our Peanut Butter ice cream combined with crushed up OREO® cookies.

Peppermint Patty
Our Peppermint ice cream with a homemade, Fudge Swirl

Pumpcan Pie
An autumn mix of Pumpkin Spice ice cream with pecan pie pieces mixed in

Rainbow Road
A festive mix of our Sweet Cream ice cream, rainbow sprinkles, chocolate chips, and marshmallows

Red Hatch Chile
Our Sweet Cream ice cream blended with pureed strawberries and a Hatch Chile infusion

Red Velvet Birthday Cake
An indulgent blend of our Cheesecake and Cold Press Vanilla ice creams with red velvet cake pieces mixed in

Red Velvet
A decadent mix of our Cheesecake ice cream and Red Velvet Cake Batter

Roasted Cherry
Roasted sweet, dark cherries blended into our Sweet Cream ice cream

Sands of Time
Time flies when you’re constantly on the run, so why not stop it for a moment and enjoy some ice cream! This Coffee ice cream mixed with cinnamon and pecan sandies is perfect for when you want some more time in life to enjoy the little things.

Siete Autumn Brunch
Our popular Gingerbread Pancake ice cream blended with molasses and Siete Churros mixed in

Texas Dirt Cake
This fan favorite is our Dark Chocolate ice cream combined with a sweetened cream cheese, lemon juice, and plenty of OREO® cookies. Think of a chocolate OREO® cheesecake kind of flavor! It’s so good!

Thin Mint
Thanks to the Girl Scouts, we were able to create this amazing flavor based on their top selling cookie! This flavor is made from our Peppermint ice cream mixed together with tons of Thin Mint cookies.

Tiramisu
Based on the popular Italian coffee flavored dessert, our Tiramisu ice cream is made with cream cheese, ground espresso, soft chocolate chips, lady finger cookies, and a splash of Kahlua Coffee Liqueur.

Vanilla Fudge Swirl
Our Cold Press Vanilla ice cream swirled together with our famous house made fudge!

White Coffee
Our White Chocolate ice cream with a coffee bean infusion!

Zilker Mint Chip
One of our top selling flavors, Zilker Mint Chip ice cream has become a staple and a must try at Amy’s. Our Zilker Mint Chip is made from our Sweet Cream ice cream that’s been mixed together with creme de menthe, peppermint oil, and of course melt in your mouth soft chocolate chips!

Zilker Mountain
Our Sweet Cream Ice Cream infused with Peppermint and Creme de Menthe with Brownie Bites stirred in.

 

Fruit Ices

Cherry Coke
A non dairy, sorbet like dessert made with classic Cherry Coke!

Cherry Limeade
The quintessential ice flavor, our Cherry Limeade ice is a non dairy, sorbet like dessert made with a mixture of lime juice and pureed roasted cherries!

Coconut Strawberry
A non dairy, sorbet like dessert made with roasted strawberries and creme de coconut

Grape Kool-Aid
A non dairy, sorbet like dessert made with Grape Kool-Aid

Mint Lemonade
A non dairy, sorbet like dessert made with lemon juice and fresh mint

 

Vegan Flavors

Oat Milk Chocolate
Our plant based ice cream made with a sweet oat milk base and blended with rich chocolate.

Oat Milk Mexican Vanilla
Our plant based ice cream made with a sweet oat milk base and our signature Mexican Vanilla extract

Vegan Chocolate
Our plant based ice cream made with a coconut milk base, cocoa, and sweetened with agave!

Vegan Mexican Vanilla
Our plant based ice cream made with a coconut milk base, our signature Mexican Vanilla extract, and sweetened with agave!

Vegan Snickerdoodle w/ Siete Mexican Cookies
Our plant based ice cream made with a coconut milk base, cinnamon, sweetened with agave, and Siete Mexican Cookies stirred in!