Join Us For The 17th Annual Trick Olympics
  • Ice Cream Cakes

    Treat yourself and your crew to an amazing hand decorated ice cream cake. Made with homemade cake from Baked by Amy’s and your favorite ice cream flavor, in the perfect size for your celebration.

Our Classic OREO®’s sweet anatomy

Just one of our many tasty flavors!

Party of 2? Party of 10? Party of 30?

Your favorite Amy’s flavors between delicious homemade cake from Baked by Amy’s hand decorated just for you. Find the perfect size, including sheet cakes, for your epic celebration. Party on!

  • Circle cakes

    • Cake sizes
        • Tiny
          3" serves 2-3
        • $15.15
        • Small
          6" serves 8-10
        • $33.50
        • Large
          8" serves 12-15
        • $48.60
    • Cake sizes
        • 1/4 Sheet Cake
          serves 15-20
        • $88.60
        • 1/2 Sheet Cake
          serves 30-42
        • $160
        • Full Sheet Cake
          serves 60-84
        • $268.95

Standard flavors

Choose from our standard flavors or let your imagination run wild as you create your own from our wide array of unique flavors.

Need something today?

Reserve a pre-made cake in-store today.

Pre-made cakes are not customizable

Order a pre-made cake

Request a custom cake

Mm...
Custom Cake

Custom cake request form

Once submitted, a team member will contact you to finalize your order.

  • Your information
  • Cake pick-up information

    • TURNAROUND TIME IS A MINIMUM OF 2 BUSINESS DAYS FROM WHEN YOUR CAKE IS CONFIRMED WITH PAYMENT OVER THE PHONE.

    • WE DO NOT DELIVER CAKES TO EACH OF THESE LOCATIONS EVERY DAY. BASED ON YOUR REQUEST, YOU MAY BE ASKED TO CHOOSE AN ALTERNATE PICKUP LOCATION.

    • Previous
    • Next
  • Cake details

    • ANY WRITING ON YOUR CAKE IS COMPLETELY COMPLIMENTARY AND DONE IN OUR HOMEMADE FUDGE. *PLEASE KEEP OUR FAMILY FRIENDLY ENVIRONMENT IN MIND WHEN DECIDING ON WHAT YOU WOULD LIKE WRITTEN ON YOUR CAKE.*

    • PLEASE NOTE: This form is a REQUEST ONLY. Your order has NOT been placed until personally confirmed by the cake department with payment over the phone. Ordering hours are Mon-Thu 8am-2pm and Fri 9am-12pm. We are closed on the weekends. All orders require a minimum turnaround of 2 business days, not including delivery time. All orders placed after business hours will be received the following business day.

    • Previous
    • Submit request